More statistics anyone?

I have blogged more about the digital skills survey results here:
 http://thevirtualleader.blogspot.co.uk/2013/12/all-i-want-for-xmas-is-more-statistics.html

More statistics about that Marmite....

I ran an online survey about the module at the end of Term 1. Here are the results so far (50 students responded).

Students do seem to dislike the delivery of the seminars in the Scale Up environment. 58% feel that the classes are NOT well organised although 74% say they get good tutor support in class and 82% feel they get equally good support outside of class. 56% say they enjoy the group based activities but 96% think the class size is too big. (The room is intended to be for 108 students seated at 12 tables each holding 9 students).

"..l have a bit of problem with the research and professional practise module.It goes very fast and the group is too big.At times l get lost whilst carrying out a task.lt takes long to get back on track."

is a fairly typical comment.

I have to agree that the size of the class is absolutely overwhelming and the much vaunted advantages of Scale Up seem not to be being realised (e.g improved attendance). It is interesting that since these problems started to emerge I have found some information on line about the well known problems of this style of teaching. These were not discussed when the pilot was mooted and volunteers sought!

From my survey and other discussions with students I would say that noise levels, the use of the microphone and cramped seating conditions are the most frequent complaints about the physical environment.

Half of the students say they have not experienced too many difficulties with the Macs (56% say they are easy to use) but that leaves 44% who have struggled and again, anecdotally, the students complain about the need to adjust to the Mac operating environment for this one class - it has slowed down their productivity and made them feel stressed and lagging behind.

Generally though the session specific satisfaction ratings are fairly positive:

60% found the sessions on digital identity to be useful
88% rated the sessions on Harvard referencing very positively :)
92% found the plagiarism and Turnitin session useful :D
82% were very satisfied with the session on search techniques using the library catalogue, databases and Google Scholar
60% also say they have learned new ITC skills in the classes.
There was quite a lot of support for sessions we ran on Evernote, Diigo and Google Drive (60% satisfaction for each), but the verdict was 60% against the use of Twitter - some enjoyed it but  the majority found it irrelevant or an intrusion on their private spaces.

A couple of positive comments were:
"its amazing what we can find for ourselves with a pc or a laptop"
 ".. it is more interesting to learn about new techniques and how you go about it,and that can boost my confidence up and be able to do a lot on the internet through my studies"
".. It is very interactive ... and I enjoy the different tasks eg. the collaborative task."

Generally I think there is something about the readiness of the class to work independently and smaller class sizes may be helpful at this point to be able to give more support to students in carrying out the group tasks. There is also an argument for putting some of this teaching into drop in workshops or integrating the skills into other tasks - even into other modules?

We have already adjusted the timetable so that the next two terms will be taught in 2 smaller groups, but still in Scale Up. The project continues....

The marmite experience

I've now finished my teaching for this module (apart from the assessment session around Easter), and gathered some written feedback from the students at the end of my last session. There's a ranking scale of 1-4, with 1 being poor, and 4 being excellent. Normally I receive 3s and 4s, but there were quite a few 1s and 2s this time. I'm trying not to take it personally, as the comments show the students either really enjoy the group work, or they hate it, so these extremes of feeling are reflected in their opinion of the session. Despite the majority (fortunately) rating the session as good or excellent, quite a few commented on the size of the class and would prefer to learn in groups, but as part of a smaller class. I felt happy at the end of my last workshop as every group made progress with the task, and not one resorted to searching Google instead of the prescribed databases. In fact, far more had a go at searching Academic Search Complete than students in previous years, so this was a positive result for them and for me.

Student mentor bogs 2

My name is Holly and I am a second year Health and Social Care student. I am a Digital Skills Mentor for the module Research and Professional Practice for the first year students studying Health and Social Care.

My experience of being a Digital Skills Mentor has been a good one. It has given me an insight in to the different ways of teaching. Having taken part in the same module last year, I think using Scale Up with the MAC computers has given the module a more interesting and interactive perspective, making it more enjoyable for the students in learning the module.

However, the Scale Up project hasn’t come without its problems. At first, the students weren’t very confident with using the MACs, as most of them had never used one before so it took time to get used to learning in this way, and using a different operating system to Windows. By the end of the first term however, the students have been much more confident in using the MACs and haven’t needed as much support in finding their way around one, for example knowing the keyboard shortcuts for copy and paste and how to use the mouse.

Also, the NOW system, for the students, took a lot of getting used to especially finding the resources for the sessions such as Padlet and the discussion boards. The class size has seemed quite big to teach for the lecturers and having smaller class sizes would maybe be a benefit but it would be difficult to fit that many seminars into one week of teaching.

However, I think having two mentors in the classroom for students has been helpful to them. Even though at first the students seemed to be quite wary of us being in the classroom, it didn’t take long for them to get used to the idea and were soon asking us for help as well as the lecturer. It has offered them help from people who have experienced and completed the module before so have an idea of what should be happening and how the tasks should be completed. It also offers them a way of getting help from someone who may know how to explain a task in a simpler way from how the lecturer may have explained it for them, to get a better understanding of what to do. Also, another benefit for the students has been that they have been able to ask us questions about second year and our experience of first year generally. Even though that’s not our reason to be in the classroom, I think the students have found it helpful being told from someone who has been through first year what it will be like and how different second year may or may not be. 

Student mentor blogs 1

Hello!

My name is Sarah Metherell, I am a 2^nd Year Health and Social Care Student/Digital Skills Mentor.

When I first started as a Digital Skills Mentor, I was excited to get started and help develop the Learning Landscape and felt this would be something I would enjoy, especially as I have a skilled background in ICT. Before we started the job we were given relevant training and introduced to all the staff we would be working with who were all very welcoming and supportive.

The role of a digital skills mentor, involves attending a first year Health and Social Care (Research and Professional Practice) class every Monday for an hour and observing the way they learn. The session I attend on the Monday is called a Scale Up session, which is a new interactive way of learning on a large scale, where students get to use MacBooks to complete activities (usually in groups) that tutors have set them. A few examples were, using Google Docs and Diigo to help students become more organized in the future when finding resources to use in their work. Another task was to create a power point presentation as a class, where each table was assigned one task each. Personally, from observing these classes, I am jealous that we were not taught using the Scale Up method in first year, as it seems engaging, interactive and fun compared to last year, where we had to sit there and listen to a power point presentation.

As the year first started off, many students seemed very shaky and unconfident using the MacBooks, but a couple of weeks later, students had begun to get the hang of using them, and I think the installation of the mouse’s most definitely helped. The majority of the students, found the tasks pretty easy to complete, although there were a few comments here and there that said the tasks can be difficult at times and sometimes boring. Also, there were some students that suggested they prefer working in smaller groups, as big groups feel very disorganised and students feel they can’t get the best possible help they can. However, the general gist of the class seem to find the tasks easygoing. The other observations I found, were usually technical difficulties such as adding a picture, or copying and pasting.

As a digital skills mentor, I was invited to attend a Learning the Landscape conference, in which those who are involved in the project gathered to discuss what could be done to develop ways of teaching. I found this very interesting and it really gave me an insight as to what the project is about.

I have very much enjoyed my first term of being a digital skills mentor and have found observing very fascinating and I look forward to the second term.